Your cart

Your cart is empty

Fall Baking Sale · October 25–31

Fall baking favorites, 20% off.

Save 20% on your baking favorites with BAKE20.

Shop online or visit Fort Collins and Aurora–Southlands. Mention BAKE20 at checkout in our shops.

Your next bake starts here

A few fall favorites for pies, cookies, apple crisp, and everything in between.

Shop all baking favorites →

October 25–31, 2026. Save 20% on eligible Baking collection products with BAKE20 online, or mention BAKE20 in Fort Collins and Aurora–Southlands. Excludes gift cards. Cannot be combined with other promotions. Online offer ends October 31 at 11:59 p.m. Mountain; in-store offer ends at each shop’s normal closing time.

Explore the full Baking collection

57 Results

57 Results

Jamaican Allspice Berries

Jamaican Allspice Berries

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Ground Ceylon Cinnamon

Ground Ceylon Cinnamon

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Black Onyx Chocolate Sugar (Salt-Free)

Black Onyx Chocolate Sugar (Salt-Free)

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Vanilla Bean Sugar

Vanilla Bean Sugar

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Ceylon Cinnamon Sticks

Ceylon Cinnamon Sticks

from $12.99

Unit price
per

from $12.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Supreme Saigon Cinnamon

Supreme Saigon Cinnamon

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Madagascar Cloves

Madagascar Cloves

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Ground Ginger

Ground Ginger

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Broken Star Anise

Broken Star Anise

from $7.49

Unit price
per

from $7.49

Unit price
per

In stock

2X Pure Madagascar Vanilla Extract - by Savory Spice

$44.95

Unit price
per

In stock

Natural Cherry Extract - by Savory Spice

$15.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Mulling Spices

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Mt. Garfield Peach Spice

Mt. Garfield Peach Spice

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Peppermint Chocolate Sugar

Peppermint Chocolate Sugar

from $12.49

Unit price
per

from $12.49

Unit price
per

In stock

Pumpkin Pie Spice

Pumpkin Pie Spice

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Salted Caramel Spice

Salted Caramel Spice

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Spiced Vanilla Bean Sugar

Spiced Vanilla Bean Sugar

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Ground Jamaican Allspice

Ground Jamaican Allspice

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Indonesian Cinnamon Sticks

Indonesian Cinnamon Sticks

from $10.99

Unit price
per

from $10.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Ground Indonesian Cinnamon

Ground Indonesian Cinnamon

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Whole Nutmeg

Whole Nutmeg

from $0.99

Unit price
per

from $0.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Ground Nutmeg

Ground Nutmeg

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Pure Maple Sugar

Pure Maple Sugar

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Natural Brandy Extract - by Savory Spice

$15.95

Unit price
per

In stock

Pure Almond Extract - by Savory Spice

Pure Almond Extract - by Savory Spice

$12.95

Unit price
per

$12.95

Unit price
per

In stock

Pure Orange Extract - by Savory Spice

Pure Orange Extract - by Savory Spice

$13.95

Unit price
per

$13.95

Unit price
per

In stock

Trailhead Chai Spice Blend (Salt-Free)

Trailhead Chai Spice Blend (Salt-Free)

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Morning Coffee Baking Spice

Morning Coffee Baking Spice

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Baking Spice

Baking Spice

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Cinnamon Sugar

Cinnamon Sugar

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Honey Butter Seasoning

Honey Butter Seasoning

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Honey Powder

Honey Powder

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Mexican Cocoa (Salt-Free)

Mexican Cocoa (Salt-Free)

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Peppermint Vanilla Bean Sugar

Peppermint Vanilla Bean Sugar

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Ground Madagascar Cloves

Ground Madagascar Cloves

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Black Onyx Cocoa Powder

Black Onyx Cocoa Powder

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Dutched Cocoa Powder

Dutched Cocoa Powder

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Sliced Crystallized Ginger

Sliced Crystallized Ginger

from $8.99

Unit price
per

from $8.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Minced Lemon Zest

Minced Lemon Zest

from $3.99

Unit price
per

from $3.99

Unit price
per

In stock

Candied Orange Peel Strips

Candied Orange Peel Strips

from $11.99

Unit price
per

from $11.99

Unit price
per

In stock